4-Way Intel P35 Motherboard Overclocking Roundup

Motherboards/Intel S775 by massman @ 2007-11-26

In this group test we compare the overclocking capabilities and performance of 4 motherboards based on the mid-range P35 Intel chipset. From the low cost Asus P5K, affordable Foxconn P35AP-S and MSI Platinum Combo to the expensive DFI P35 Lanparty, which one will come out on top? Find out in this article.

  • prev
  • next

MSI Platinum Combo: Box, bundle and board

Box, inside and outside

These days, fancy packaging becomes more and more important. People can literally buy their motherboard in a store and choose between different models. People need to know what the board is capable of when they look at the box. The one with the best looking design and most information often is first choice.

MSI's box is quite shiny (maybe difficult to see on the pictures). The light reflection of the box is nice.

Madshrimps (c)

Madshrimps (c)


Opening the box we find the accessories on top of the motherboard, which is wrapped in an antistatic bag.

Madshrimps (c)


The board comes with a pretty complete bundle :

  • 4 sata cables
  • 2 molex to sata power convertors
  • I/O backplate
  • Ide cable
  • Floppy cable
  • Driver disk for both XP and Vista
  • IEEE1394 bracket
  • Motherboards manual
  • A quick start guide

    Madshrimps (c)


    All of this is nice of course, but there's only one component inside which really matters:

    Madshrimps (c)


    The motherboard and its features

    Let me guide you around this motherboard, starting with the CPU socket area.

    Madshrimps (c)


    As you can see, the socket area is not at all that spacious. The special designed heatsink Circu-Pipe is placed around the cpu area, cooling down the mosfets, the northbridge and the southbridge. The Circu-Pipe reminds me of a rollercoaster ... I wonder why.

    Madshrimps (c)
    Are you ready to thrill on this rollercoaster?


    The Circu-Pipe has the advantage of keeping the temperatures of the chipset cool enough to allow users to set the voltage of the northbridge a bit higher. However, not everything is swell : The engineers from MSI decided to put the 8-pin power connector under the copper pipes going from the mosfets to the northbridge. Luckily, they've overcome this situation quite innovative by lengthening the power connector.

    Madshrimps (c)
    No more hassle when installing the 8-pin power connector


    For our enthusiast readers I've included a clear photo of the socket area in order to inform you how difficult it is to insulate the area. As you can see, it won't be that easy, although I've seen more difficult boards.

    Madshrimps (c)


    Continuing the tour, we arrive at the I/O panel.

    Madshrimps (c)


    These are the backpanel connectors :

  • PS/2 keyboard and mouse
  • 2 x eSata
  • 6 in 1 audio
  • 6 x USB 2.0
  • Gigabit lan
  • IEEE1394
  • Optical SPDIF out

    Quite complete, I must say, 6 usb ports is more than enough these days. The support for both PS/2 keyboard and mouse is well-chosen as many people still use those.

    Next, we arrive at the PCIe slots:

    Madshrimps (c)


    Nothing special to say, almost all motherboards feature two x16 PCIe slots for using CrossFire. There’s more than enough space between two slots to be able to use dual slot cooling solutions.

    Next up, the internal I/O connections.

    Madshrimps (c)


    No remarks at all about the availability of connections, quite complete:

  • 1 CPU and 5 System connectors
  • CD-in connector
  • Front panel audio connector
  • Front panel connector
  • SPDIF-out pinheader
  • Chasis intrusion connector
  • Serial port pinheader
  • 3 USB 2.0 connectors
  • Floppy disk drive connector
  • 5 Serial ATAII connectors
  • ATA133 connector
  • IEEE1394 connector support additional 1 port
  • H/W OC pinheaders

    The only thing we'd like to mention is the new way of clearing the cmos. MSI opted for a small button instead of the classic jumper.

    Madshrimps (c)


    The tour's almost finished, the only area we have to pass is memory land.

    Madshrimps (c)


    As the name of the motherboard already revealed, this board supports both DDR2 and DDR3 memory. You can't mix DDR2 with DDR3 though, as you have to lock the memory slots you're not using. MSI designed a special memory slot locker (new word for the English dictionary ;-) ) on which they've added LEDs to create a nice visual aspect, useless if you're not a case-modder, nice feature if you are.

    Madshrimps (c)

    Madshrimps (c)
    • prev
    • next
    Comment from Rutar @ 2007/11/26
    the madshrimps roundup attack on motherboard reviews, I'd be affraid if I was still writing the outdated one motherboard reviews


    Foxconn really works on their street cred with that board
    Comment from geoffrey @ 2007/11/26
    Owning a P5K myself, good performance considering its price, and not too overloaded with BIOS features which hardly make a difference and are too complicated to understand for people who just jumped in.

    Liked the article btw
    Comment from Sidney @ 2007/11/26
    Can't beat the Asus P5K board in both price and performance.
    Comment from Massman @ 2007/11/27
    You can by overclocking
    Comment from jmke @ 2007/11/27
    if you overclock,how will you beat the price/performance value? since FSB OCing hardly has any effect in real world applications
    Comment from Rutar @ 2007/11/27
    I think it would be more noticable with a Quadcore, where the Vdrop is more important.
    Comment from Massman @ 2007/11/27
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by jmke View Post
    if you overclock,how will you beat the price/performance value? since FSB OCing hardly has any effect in real world applications
    You and me have different definitions of overclocking . I see it as benching, you as cost-effective performance tweaking. In other words, I am willing to pay 45€ extra for a board which is faster, you're not.
    Comment from thorgal @ 2007/11/28
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Massman View Post
    You and me have different definitions of overclocking . I see it as benching, you as cost-effective performance tweaking. In other words, I am willing to pay 45€ extra for a board which is faster, you're not.
    I can second that, so am I But the majority of people are not, unfortunately for the hardware vendors
    Comment from jmke @ 2007/11/28
    but Massman, as a reviewer you'll have to look at both sides of the overclocking approach
    Comment from Massman @ 2007/11/28
    That's why the Price/Perfomance winner =/= High-end winner
    Comment from jmke @ 2007/11/29
    nope
    Comment from Kougar @ 2007/12/02
    45nm support on 975X chipsets is iffy, best to check on a individual board by board basis. Some sites have run 45nm chips on 975X ASUS boards however.

    Interesting review! Am I correct that the ASUS P5k only has 3 vRegs? That's pitiful, no wonder there are reports that Quadcores would kill the thing. Does explain the 0.1v vdroop problem too, my own 3vReg DS3 had about that same vdroop also with a E6300. To bad Gigabyte didn't show up to the party.

     

    reply