Nowadays computers draw more and more power. Especially when there is an Intel Pres(c)(h)ott CPU or nVidia's 6800 series videocard inside, to mention a few...
And if you want to spice things up by overclocking, the power usage will grow exponentially... Thus a decent power supply is needed.
For the last two months I've been collecting and testing power supplies. Thanks to the help of many shops and producers, I was able to test 14 PSU's. Including some flashy modded samples, some high power beasts, and even some fanless, passive cooled PSU's.
First of all I want to apologize for the long time it took to finish all the tests, my setup broke down twice. Not due to PSU failures, rather, events better be best described as “end-user errors”; dropping a screw on a running A64 motherboard wasn't advisable, trying to remove it with metal pliers even less.
13 out of 14 PSU's were tested on the following setup:
Piotke's Test Setup
|CPU ||AMD Athlon 64 3000+ @ 2.4 Ghz 1.7 Vcore |
|Mainboard ||Shuttle AN50R|
|Cooling ||Thermalright SLK948 U|
|Memory ||2* 256 MB Corsair PC3500 @ 200 Mhz 2-2-2-5|
|Video||Sapphire Radeon 9800 XT|
|HDD||Seagate Cuda 5 7200.7 120 Gb |
|Optical ||Nec 2500 A DVD R |
The last PSU, from Silverstone was tested on a different setup, but this will be explained later on.
And here you have a teaser picture, made somewhere halfway the tests:FSP FSP300-60PN(PF)
FSP Aurora - FSP350-60PN(PF)
TASK TK-945TX-DF (450W)
Antec TrueControl 550W
Global Win SAF Eleel 380W
Global Win SAF Leleel 450W
How I tested the PSU’s
Let me also explain how I tested.
First I hot wired the PSU so I could use it without computer, and I measured the voltages with a multi-meter to check for inconsistencies, I scribbled the values down and will include them in the data comparison graph at the end as a reference only.
Then I hooked up the PSU to the system specified above, again I monitored the voltages with a multi-meter, using the external connectors from the PSU.
Finally I used the computer for a while, stress testing, surfing, gaming.. you know.. PC stuff. MBM registered values from the +3.3 V, +5 V and +12 V lines.
I have more than one model from certain brands. I covered each brand separately and dedicated one page per brand with brief data sheet only to include critical and interesting facts without chit-chat to get to the "meat".
The short introduction became longer then I expected, so let's go directly to the FSP PSU's-->