USPTO has 'tentatively' invalidated Apple's key rubber-banding patent

Stefan Mileschin · 24th October 2012, 08:23

The US Patent and Trademark Office may have just thrown a wrench into Apple's recent courtroom triumph over Samsung by invalidating one of the patents at the heart of the victory: rubber-banding. We noted at the time that Apple hit a "home run" with that particular IP, as jurors declared that all 21 disputed Samsung devices infringed it, no doubt resulting in a large part of the $1 billion (and counting) owed by the Korean maker. "Claim 19" of patent 7469381, which covers that feature, was invalidated by the USPTO on two counts, both of which were cases of prior art that allegedly existed before Cupertino claimed them. Either one could be enough reason to throw out that part of the patent, according to FOSS Patents, provided that the USPTO's ruling stands up. Either way, Samsung has already brought the new information to Judge Koh's attention -- which might bring about some new action very soon.

http://www.engadget.com/2012/10/23/f...ubber-banding/

24th October 2012, 08:23	#1
Stefan Mileschin [M] Reviewer Join Date: May 2010 Location: Romania Posts: 148,597	USPTO has 'tentatively' invalidated Apple's key rubber-banding patent The US Patent and Trademark Office may have just thrown a wrench into Apple's recent courtroom triumph over Samsung by invalidating one of the patents at the heart of the victory: rubber-banding. We noted at the time that Apple hit a "home run" with that particular IP, as jurors declared that all 21 disputed Samsung devices infringed it, no doubt resulting in a large part of the $1 billion (and counting) owed by the Korean maker. "Claim 19" of patent 7469381, which covers that feature, was invalidated by the USPTO on two counts, both of which were cases of prior art that allegedly existed before Cupertino claimed them. Either one could be enough reason to throw out that part of the patent, according to FOSS Patents, provided that the USPTO's ruling stands up. Either way, Samsung has already brought the new information to Judge Koh's attention -- which might bring about some new action very soon. http://www.engadget.com/2012/10/23/f...ubber-banding/

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Canon recalls 68,200 EOS Rebel T4i DSLRs, says rubber grips can lead to skin rash	Stefan Mileschin	WebNews	0	15th August 2012 06:36
German court rules Motorola Xoom doesn't violate Apple's iPad design patent	Stefan Mileschin	WebNews	0	18th July 2012 07:47
Apple's A5X Floorplan	Stefan Mileschin	WebNews	0	19th March 2012 06:52
Zalman AMP1000 Aluminum-Rubber Mousepad Starts Selling	Stefan Mileschin	WebNews	0	29th December 2011 09:57
Girl, Apple's gonna make you sweat with a treadmill patent	Stefan Mileschin	WebNews	0	3rd November 2011 07:54
Apple's iOS 5 Already Jailbroken	jmke	WebNews	0	7th June 2011 14:25
Apple's MacBook Pro: Using it as a Mac and a PC	jmke	WebNews	0	13th April 2006 09:10