windwithme’s Core i7 review Part 11-MSI X58M Micro-ATX OC Review

windwithme · 4th August 2009, 17:15

X58 chipset has been introduced to the market for 9 months, and is still on top-of-the-range of Intel product line.
For some main board manufacturers, Micro ATX is no longer a low-priced product.
Ever since DFI released its first Micro ATX X58 in January, MSI and Asus started to include Micro ATX in high performance product category.

As we analyzed the OC performance of DFI JR X58 in last episode, I believe most of you have basic understanding of X58 Micro ATX.
This time, we have MSI X58M which is a rare X58 Micor ATX in the market.
The lowest price for X58 ATX is around US$200, X58 Micro ATX will lower than that price.
We would like to introduce you MSI X58M which is a price-valued Micro ATX.

The spec of X58M changes the concepts of cheap, less function, just enough performance, and low grade for Micro ATX.
X58M allows Micro ATX users to experience high grade computer structure, in the meantime, the expandability and support have greatly improved.

Let’s take a look at the package

User’s manual. Driver and software CD. Cords. CrossFire connector.

MSI X58M

Lower left of the main board
2 X PCIE X16 supports CrossFire and SLI, bandwidth X16+X16
1 X PCI
There is a power button down below.

Lower right of the main board
7 X SATAII(ICH10R, Raid 0/1/5)
1 X Floppy
1 X IDE

Upper right of the main board
6 X DIMM DDR3, DDR3 800/1066/1333(OC)
power input

Upper left of the main board
6 phase power supply. Active Power Switch
Cooling device also provides LGA775 which only can be found on FOXCONN X58 before.
This will save consumers’ money on purchasing high-end cooling device.

IO
6 X USB 2.0
1 X 1394a
1 X eSATA

MOSFET material

windwithme · 4th August 2009, 17:23

North bridge cooling module

Screen shot when system is turned on.

BIOS main page

Cell Menu

CPU Voltage -0.320~+630mV
CPU PLL Voltage 1.00~1.85V
QPI Voltage 0.88~1.83V
DRAM Voltage 1.20~2.77V

Through MEMORY-Z, detail setup of SPD can be viewed.

DRAM advanced parameter setup

H/W Monitor

The BIOS setup above is what I usually use on X58M which the CPU is quite stable when external clock is set to 218MHz.
Different CPU has different results from different BIOS setup.

Testing platform
CPU: Intel Core i7 950
MB: MSI X58M
DRAM: CORSAIR XMS3 TR3X6G1600C8
VGA: GIGABYTE GTX260 OC SLI
HD: CORSAIR CMFSSD-64GB2D
POWER: CORSAIR HX1000W Modular Power Supply
Cooler: Megahalems

CPU OC 218 X 19 => 4150Mhz
DDR3 1748 CL9 9-9-24 1T

Hyper 8 X PI 32M 13m 48.734s
CPUMARK 99 650

windwithme · 4th August 2009, 17:39

CrystalMark 2004R3

CINEBENCH R10

PCMark Vantage 16444

X58M has quite good OC performance. Compare with X58 ATX, the performance is nearly no difference.
External clock is one of its advantages as well. During the test, it is easy to reach 218 MHz.

DDR3 1748 CL8 8-8-24 1T
Sandra Memory Bandwidth-29895MB/s
EVEREST Memory Read-18845MB/s

CORSAIR P64 SSD, MLC 64GB

When raise the clock of DDR3, the performance is not as good as expected.
ICH10R southbridge chip equips with CORSAIR high performance MLC SSD, the bandwidth is amazing.
ATTO reaches 227/153 MB/s.

GTX 260 SLI
3DMARK VANTAGE 21189

Crysis Benchmark

StreetFighter IV Benchmark
1680 X 1050 21963

1920 X 1200 18735

Biohazard5 Benchmark

With great 3D support from X58 chipset, remarkable 3D effect can be performed with dual-VGA technology from ATI or NVIDIA.
By considering the available space in the ordinary chassis, the best choice for graphics cards are 9600 SLI and 4850 CF.

windwithme · 4th August 2009, 17:50

MSI X58M
Advantage
1. High performance Micro ATX of X58 product.
2. All Japanese made solid capacitors. Debug signal. Built-in power botton.
3. Support ATI CrossFire and NVIDIA SLI.
4. Rich BIOS options. Wide range of power voltage. Outstanding external clock.
5. Price competitive amongst available M-ATX X58 in the market.

Disadvantage
1. No cooling module above MOSFET
2. DDR3 OC performance is not as good as expected.
3. The temperature of northbridge is a bit high. Adopt larger cooling pipe will solve the problem.

Performance: ★★★★★★★☆☆☆
Components design: ★★★★★★★☆☆☆
Specification: ★★★★★★★★☆☆
The appearance: ★★★★★★★★☆☆
C/P Ratio: ★★★★★★★★★☆

The major issue of X58M is in DDR3 OC performance.
As indicate in the spec, DDR3 1333 can be achieved under the condition of overclocking.
The default 133 MHz CPU clock can only reach DDR3 800 or 1066.
Compare with other competitors, MSI X58M will require some improvement in this part.

Intel new LGA1156 CPU will become available in the market in two months.
For the entry level X58, the price is around US$200 which is still quite competitive comparing with P55.
My wild guess of the price for the middle to high grade P55 is around US$150-250.
P55 will not be price competitive at beginning.

The price of the MSI X58M is fairly competitive.
The price of X58 is NT$5000, equivalent to US$152 which is very attractive to the users who are looking for X58 platform with limited budget.

thorgal · 5th August 2009, 06:34

Thanks for the great review WWM, hadn't seen this board yet

4th August 2009, 17:15	#1
windwithme Eastern OC Expert Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 1,092	windwithme’s Core i7 review Part 11-MSI X58M Micro-ATX OC Review X58 chipset has been introduced to the market for 9 months, and is still on top-of-the-range of Intel product line. For some main board manufacturers, Micro ATX is no longer a low-priced product. Ever since DFI released its first Micro ATX X58 in January, MSI and Asus started to include Micro ATX in high performance product category. As we analyzed the OC performance of DFI JR X58 in last episode, I believe most of you have basic understanding of X58 Micro ATX. This time, we have MSI X58M which is a rare X58 Micor ATX in the market. The lowest price for X58 ATX is around US$200, X58 Micro ATX will lower than that price. We would like to introduce you MSI X58M which is a price-valued Micro ATX. The spec of X58M changes the concepts of cheap, less function, just enough performance, and low grade for Micro ATX. X58M allows Micro ATX users to experience high grade computer structure, in the meantime, the expandability and support have greatly improved. Let’s take a look at the package User’s manual. Driver and software CD. Cords. CrossFire connector. MSI X58M Lower left of the main board 2 X PCIE X16 supports CrossFire and SLI, bandwidth X16+X16 1 X PCI There is a power button down below. Lower right of the main board 7 X SATAII(ICH10R, Raid 0/1/5) 1 X Floppy 1 X IDE Upper right of the main board 6 X DIMM DDR3, DDR3 800/1066/1333(OC) power input Upper left of the main board 6 phase power supply. Active Power Switch Cooling device also provides LGA775 which only can be found on FOXCONN X58 before. This will save consumers’ money on purchasing high-end cooling device. IO 6 X USB 2.0 1 X 1394a 1 X eSATA MOSFET material

5th August 2009, 06:34	#5
thorgal [M] Reviewer Join Date: Sep 2005 Posts: 1,887	Thanks for the great review WWM, hadn't seen this board yet __________________

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Analytic cooler for the best buy of Intel Micro ATX with Core i3-530	windwithme	Hardware Overclocking and Case Modding	4	25th April 2010 14:35
MSI Radeon HD 5870 review	jmke	WebNews	0	2nd October 2009 12:19
windwithme’s Core i7 review Part 6-DFI LANParty DK X58-T3eH6 Extreme performance	windwithme	Hardware Overclocking and Case Modding	3	7th April 2009 17:32
windwithme’s Core i7 review Part 4-DFI LANParty UT X58-T3eH8 overclocking	windwithme	Hardware Overclocking and Case Modding	6	15th March 2009 02:25
In Win Matrix Tiny Tower Micro ATX Case Review	jmke	WebNews	0	7th January 2009 14:30
Apevia X-Qboii Micro ATX Case Review	jmke	WebNews	0	14th October 2008 19:54
Antec Minuet II Micro ATX Case	Sidney	WebNews	0	10th November 2005 14:31
Athlon 64 X2 4800+ Dual Core Review	Sidney	WebNews	0	9th May 2005 16:03

4th August 2009, 17:23	#2
windwithme Eastern OC Expert Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 1,092	North bridge cooling module Screen shot when system is turned on. BIOS main page Cell Menu CPU Voltage -0.320~+630mV CPU PLL Voltage 1.00~1.85V QPI Voltage 0.88~1.83V DRAM Voltage 1.20~2.77V Through MEMORY-Z, detail setup of SPD can be viewed. DRAM advanced parameter setup H/W Monitor The BIOS setup above is what I usually use on X58M which the CPU is quite stable when external clock is set to 218MHz. Different CPU has different results from different BIOS setup. Testing platform CPU: Intel Core i7 950 MB: MSI X58M DRAM: CORSAIR XMS3 TR3X6G1600C8 VGA: GIGABYTE GTX260 OC SLI HD: CORSAIR CMFSSD-64GB2D POWER: CORSAIR HX1000W Modular Power Supply Cooler: Megahalems CPU OC 218 X 19 => 4150Mhz DDR3 1748 CL9 9-9-24 1T Hyper 8 X PI 32M 13m 48.734s CPUMARK 99 650

4th August 2009, 17:39	#3
windwithme Eastern OC Expert Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 1,092	CrystalMark 2004R3 CINEBENCH R10 PCMark Vantage 16444 X58M has quite good OC performance. Compare with X58 ATX, the performance is nearly no difference. External clock is one of its advantages as well. During the test, it is easy to reach 218 MHz. DDR3 1748 CL8 8-8-24 1T Sandra Memory Bandwidth-29895MB/s EVEREST Memory Read-18845MB/s CORSAIR P64 SSD, MLC 64GB When raise the clock of DDR3, the performance is not as good as expected. ICH10R southbridge chip equips with CORSAIR high performance MLC SSD, the bandwidth is amazing. ATTO reaches 227/153 MB/s. GTX 260 SLI 3DMARK VANTAGE 21189 Crysis Benchmark StreetFighter IV Benchmark 1680 X 1050 21963 1920 X 1200 18735 Biohazard5 Benchmark With great 3D support from X58 chipset, remarkable 3D effect can be performed with dual-VGA technology from ATI or NVIDIA. By considering the available space in the ordinary chassis, the best choice for graphics cards are 9600 SLI and 4850 CF.

4th August 2009, 17:50	#4
windwithme Eastern OC Expert Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 1,092	MSI X58M Advantage 1. High performance Micro ATX of X58 product. 2. All Japanese made solid capacitors. Debug signal. Built-in power botton. 3. Support ATI CrossFire and NVIDIA SLI. 4. Rich BIOS options. Wide range of power voltage. Outstanding external clock. 5. Price competitive amongst available M-ATX X58 in the market. Disadvantage 1. No cooling module above MOSFET 2. DDR3 OC performance is not as good as expected. 3. The temperature of northbridge is a bit high. Adopt larger cooling pipe will solve the problem. Performance: ★★★★★★★☆☆☆ Components design: ★★★★★★★☆☆☆ Specification: ★★★★★★★★☆☆ The appearance: ★★★★★★★★☆☆ C/P Ratio: ★★★★★★★★★☆ The major issue of X58M is in DDR3 OC performance. As indicate in the spec, DDR3 1333 can be achieved under the condition of overclocking. The default 133 MHz CPU clock can only reach DDR3 800 or 1066. Compare with other competitors, MSI X58M will require some improvement in this part. Intel new LGA1156 CPU will become available in the market in two months. For the entry level X58, the price is around US$200 which is still quite competitive comparing with P55. My wild guess of the price for the middle to high grade P55 is around US$150-250. P55 will not be price competitive at beginning. The price of the MSI X58M is fairly competitive. The price of X58 is NT$5000, equivalent to US$152 which is very attractive to the users who are looking for X58 platform with limited budget.