| Thread Tools |
11th October 2012, 06:39 | #1 |
[M] Reviewer Join Date: May 2010 Location: Romania
Posts: 148,462
| US jury to test IP address as proof of hacking A US jury is about to make a landmark decision as to whether an IP address can be used to identify a software pirate. Cases bought and paid for by Big Content depend on identifying the IP address of machines, but experts have questioned whether the IP address is sufficient evidence because it identifies an internet connection rather than a person. A porn company, Malibu Media, has instigated 349 mass lawsuits, 43 in Pennsylvania this year. Most of the cases are settled out of court because the company was armed with an IP address and it could threaten users with settlement demands. But in one lawsuit, five of the anonymous defendants protested when their internet service providers were ordered to reveal their identities. They accused Malibu Media of pursuing the cases "to extort settlements". Judge Michael Baylson, of the Pennsylvania District Court, said that the accused claimed BitTorrent does not work in the manner the plaintiff alleges. "A mere subscriber to an ISP is not necessarily a copyright infringer, with explanations as to how computer-based technology would allow non-subscribers to access a particular IP address," he said. There is no reason to assume an ISP subscriber is the same person who may be using BitTorrent to download the alleged copyrighted material. He said that a trial was needed "to decide who's right". According to TorrentFreak the trial will set an important precedent. If the jury agrees that the IP address cannot identify a user, then US courts will not be allowed to insist that addresses are handed over to copyright holders. It will also mean that copyright holders will not be allowed to threaten users with expensive court cases without finding other methods of proof. http://news.techeye.net/security/us-...oof-of-hacking |
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Plantiffs' Counsel Announces that Federal Jury Finds Toshiba Fixed LCD Prices | Stefan Mileschin | WebNews | 0 | 5th July 2012 06:41 |
Jury issues verdict in Android suit, finds that Google doesn't infringe Oracle patent | Stefan Mileschin | WebNews | 0 | 24th May 2012 08:21 |
Jury mulls Oracle and Google war | Stefan Mileschin | WebNews | 0 | 2nd May 2012 08:16 |
Jury Says Verdict Close in $1B Microsoft Lawsuit | Stefan Mileschin | WebNews | 0 | 19th December 2011 07:00 |
AMD to Address the Market of Tablets in 2012 | jmke | WebNews | 0 | 10th November 2010 08:09 |
Use Facebook to Escape Jury Duty | jmke | WebNews | 0 | 2nd February 2009 16:09 |
Jury Awards $11.3M For Internet Defamation | jmke | WebNews | 1 | 12th October 2006 16:20 |
Thread Tools | |
| |