Editorial: Let Google be a little evil

Stefan Mileschin · 14th May 2013, 07:19

Google's lawyers visited the Second Circuit Court of Appeals last week for a polite conversation with three judges and attorneys from the Authors Guild. You remember -- the book-scanning thing? Yes, the case is 7 years old and still unresolved. The Circuit Court is just a way station in a longer journey -- at issue is whether the Authors Guild's class action suit should be broken apart, forcing authors and publishers to confront Google individually.

Google is going to win this thing eventually. If that makes Google evil, it is a necessary evil.

The bigger question is about the lawfulness of Google's digital library quest, and the legitimacy of the Guild's copyright charges and request for damages. There are points of similarity to the music industry's litigation saga. And major differences. Google is going to win this thing eventually. If that makes Google evil, it is a necessary evil.

http://www.engadget.com/2013/05/13/l... ign=Engadget

14th May 2013, 07:19	#1
Stefan Mileschin [M] Reviewer Join Date: May 2010 Location: Romania Posts: 148,553	Editorial: Let Google be a little evil Google's lawyers visited the Second Circuit Court of Appeals last week for a polite conversation with three judges and attorneys from the Authors Guild. You remember -- the book-scanning thing? Yes, the case is 7 years old and still unresolved. The Circuit Court is just a way station in a longer journey -- at issue is whether the Authors Guild's class action suit should be broken apart, forcing authors and publishers to confront Google individually. Google is going to win this thing eventually. If that makes Google evil, it is a necessary evil. The bigger question is about the lawfulness of Google's digital library quest, and the legitimacy of the Guild's copyright charges and request for damages. There are points of similarity to the music industry's litigation saga. And major differences. Google is going to win this thing eventually. If that makes Google evil, it is a necessary evil. http://www.engadget.com/2013/05/13/l... ign=Engadget

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Editorial: Does Windows Phone even have a chance without Google?	Stefan Mileschin	WebNews	0	17th December 2012 09:31
Resident Evil 6 is nearly here	Stefan Mileschin	WebNews	0	25th September 2012 07:47
Editorial: What we want to see in iOS 6	Stefan Mileschin	WebNews	0	12th June 2012 06:21
China Hacks Google Servers, Google decides to remove content filter on Google.cn	jmke	WebNews	0	13th January 2010 15:39
Editorial: Where NVIDIA went wrong with the GTX 280	jmke	WebNews	10	19th June 2008 09:22
AMD K10 Editorial	jmke	WebNews	0	3rd July 2007 20:52
Intel Core 2 Editorial	jmke	WebNews	0	11th July 2006 10:37
Resident Evil 4	jmke	WebNews	0	3rd March 2005 09:47
The Paperless Office Editorial	Sidney	WebNews	1	5th October 2004 23:36
Editorial on Digital Audio	Sidney	WebNews	0	2nd October 2004 01:00