Humor Reading: Tweakguides bans all users asking questions:)

jmke · 31st January 2009, 18:28

Browsing through this forum http://forums.tweakguides.com/forumdisplay.php?f=17 is like reading a "how not to run a forum" manual; if you register their forum with the intent to ask a question, you'll be banned

Quote:

Having become an invited member today, you have proceeded to immediately make several posts which contribute absolutely nothing to the forums. Two of them are unresearched questions to your benefit (here and here), and one is a completely non-productive and frivolous comment in a tech thread here.

Quote:

This is not a tech support forum. Thread closed, user banned.

Quote:

Well after all that, it seems digitalforce, promising to contribute some "important information" simply joined up to ask a question so basic that it is impossible that he had done any research to answer it himself. This should have been obvious based on his urgency to join, his somewhat dubious introduction title, the fact that he didn't appear to have read the introduction sticky very well.

Quote:

You are clearly here to just comment/post on one issue, and as pointed out in the introduction sticky, joining just to make a comment is not a valid reason for becoming an invited member. If you have important information about SecuROM you can email them me and I can post them in the SecuROM thread (and credit you with them) if they are verified facts. Thread closed, user banned.

Quote:

This is not a tech support forum, joining just to seek help or provide help with a single issue is not acceptable. Thread closed, user banned.

list goes on; just crazy

jmke · 31st January 2009, 19:08

does give me an idea for countering the spam mails; I had first blocked all free email accounts; but that is not very user friendly; I tweaked the system now, all email addresses are accepted, but before a newly registered user can post in the forums, he has to post an introduction in the " Welcome to our forums! " thread; afterwards a moderator needs to give him some reputation points; than after 5minutes the user will be moved to a user group which can post and reply everywhere

let's see how that works

Massman · 31st January 2009, 20:34

Seems like the forums wil be closed soon

Quote:

Well unfortunately, after thinking about this issue for many months, and of course especially over the past 24 hours, I've come to the conclusion that I just can't keep the forums running any longer. Changing the rules or procedures any further is not going to do much in the end. For one reason or another, the vast majority of readers simply do not seem to be interested in the type of forums I want to provide, and I'm not interested in diluting my personal philosophy and vision of what my forums should be just to accommodate them. This inherent conflict between what readers want and what I want makes keeping these forums running untenable for me.

I don't have the time or the patience to keep investing many hours each week into Admining the forums, especially as they provide no income and simply sap the time I could be putting into writing guides and doing other work to actually help pay my bills. I've tried to have a range of people assist me in moderating the forums, but ultimately for one reason or another the bulk of the work falls to me to perform, and it is particularly unpleasant work at that. As a result I regularly receive abusive emails from people who don't make it through the Introduction system, as well as the usual excuses and argumentative messages from existing members who breach the rules. The entire process now leaves a bad taste in my mouth, making it an absolute chore that dogs me day after day with no break. It also brings out the worst in me, and in turn only negatively affects the main site.

I am genuinely surprised that despite the many prompts, obstacles and stickies clearly pointing out the way things work here and explaining the rationale behind the rules, most people truly don't seem to want to understand that the TweakGuides Forums were designed as a niche high quality forum targetted towards a particular audience and with particular aims - they just want a free tech support forum so they can be spoonfed answers, or a place to perpetuate the usual mindless drivel that is on display in most forums these days. Neither of these reasons are acceptable to me as a basis for a forum. I was never interested in replicating the many existing forums already on the Internet, and I don't much care about being popular; I wanted to provide an alternative for people like me who were fed up with those other forums, a place shielded from the lowest common denominator garbage prevalent around the Internet. In the end, as I've said, this has proven unviable with the resources currently at my disposal.

In any case I make absolutely no apologies for attempting to do something different, but I do want to apologize to the key members here who have contributed a great deal to the forums and have provided interesting discussions and useful information. I won't name them as I'm sure we all know who they are. Thank you to those individuals and I wish you all the best, it was a pleasure interacting with you, and I'm sorry the forums had to end this way.

I don't want to draw things out any futher, so I will effectively be shutting down the forums permanently within the next hour. However rather than closing them completely, to allow people to continue to potentially benefit from the information already posted here, I will make the forums 'read only'; no new posts will be allowed, but everyone will still be able to browse the forums.

jmke · 31st January 2009, 22:18

he closed the forums 22/10 last year, from one day to the next
he has a thriving community forum and shuts it down because people don't "discuss" the way he wants them too; sad

31st January 2009, 19:08	#2
jmke Madshrimp Join Date: May 2002 Location: 7090/Belgium Posts: 78,416	does give me an idea for countering the spam mails; I had first blocked all free email accounts; but that is not very user friendly; I tweaked the system now, all email addresses are accepted, but before a newly registered user can post in the forums, he has to post an introduction in the " Welcome to our forums! " thread; afterwards a moderator needs to give him some reputation points; than after 5minutes the user will be moved to a user group which can post and reply everywhere let's see how that works __________________

31st January 2009, 22:18	#4
jmke Madshrimp Join Date: May 2002 Location: 7090/Belgium Posts: 78,416	he closed the forums 22/10 last year, from one day to the next he has a thriving community forum and shuts it down because people don't "discuss" the way he wants them too; sad __________________

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Elgato releases EyeTV HD for Mac users	Shogun	WebNews	0	26th May 2010 00:10
Noctua provides free NM-A90 Upgrade-Kit for AMD users	jmke	WebNews	0	1st April 2010 07:35
Sapphire HD 5770 BIOS Botchup Leaves Users with Just 720 Stream Processors	jmke	WebNews	0	24th December 2009 10:43
TweakGuides Tweaking Companion for Windows 7	jmke	WebNews	0	27th November 2009 09:42
Noob LN2, Dewar questions	Expat GriZ	Air - Water - Peltier - Phase Change - LN2 Cooling Projects	3	7th March 2009 19:53
TweakGuides Tweaking Companion	jmke	WebNews	0	6th July 2007 06:40
Firefox users lead the way in keeping up to date	jmke	WebNews	0	18th May 2007 16:54
Noctua offers free AM2 Upgrade-Kits for NH-U12 and NH-U9 users	jmke	WebNews	0	12th July 2006 15:44
Will Microsoft sue OpenOffice users?	jmke	WebNews	0	17th September 2004 10:32