20 heatsinks reviewed and compared

@ 2005/12/29
* Akasa Evo 120
* Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 Pro
* Asetek Vapochill Micro
* Cooler Master Hyper 48
* Gigabyte G-Power Pro
* Gigabyte G-Power Lite
* Intel Box
* Noctua NH-U9
* Noctua NH-U12
* Scythe Ninja
* Thermalright XP-90
* Thermalright XP-90c
* Thermalright XP-120
* Titan Vanessa S-Type
* Titan Vanessa L-Type
* Tuniq Tower 120
* Zalman CNPS 7700 AlCu
* Zalman CNPS 7700 Cu
* Zalman CNPS 7700 Fatl1ty
* Zalman CNPS 9500 LED

http://babelfish.altavista.com/babel...ds%2Fpage1.php

(For noise vs. temperature @ 5, 7, 9 and 12V, go to page 18)
Comment from jmke @ 2005/12/29
8 in total
Comment from Gothrek @ 2005/12/29
of about 4 heatsinks
Comment from jmke @ 2005/12/29
those XBit labs tests are roundups
Comment from Gothrek @ 2005/12/29
i have lots of reviews of BT jmke, but i dont understand that every time there is a big round up, they are not part of it
Comment from jmke @ 2005/12/29
stop yer whining
compared to Scythe Ninja & Zalman CNPS9500LED http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/coo...5-cool_24.html

compared to Titan Vanessa L/S and Zalman CNPS9500LED
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/coo...l-comp_12.html

google baby!

in 1st test Shogun performance less than Ninja; in my test it's the reverse
Comment from Gothrek @ 2005/12/29
Still no TT BT :grum:
Comment from Sidney @ 2005/12/29
1) 90nm AMD A64 runs cool
2) It was written almost two years ago.
3) I still like to have the 3-year warranty since I don't change CPU as often as the young folks.
Comment from jmke @ 2005/12/29
that's a nice article you wrote there, very interesting, the conclusion near the end needs to more elaborate though. In an open test bed, the "bad" heatsinks do "good" because they get lots of free air. The large heatsinks will perform awesome in a case, and show a larger improvement over the stock cooling, when things get "hot"
Comment from Sidney @ 2005/12/29
The same reason your test using the same setup is valid in the comparison, although my thought remains unchanged since in-case test yields more actual temp and noise.

http://www.home.earthlink.net/~lazym...0Selection.htm
Comment from jmke @ 2005/12/29
that's some very nice testing, must have taken him plenty of time; if I'm not mistaken he's an employee in a computer store; and get his hands on plenty of hardware to test.

29 tests at 4 different fan speeds, approx ~116 hours worth of tests without mounting time included; YAY! I spent close to 140 hours with "only" 89 test configs, but needed to install them inside case (motherboard removal for some) which eats a lot more time.

I have nothing to add to his findings, only remark I can make is about the test setup; testing inside a case will give certain HSF an advantage (tower heatsinks) and others a disadvantage (xp-120 and similar). In an open testbed you get very artificial results, not always a representation of real-life performance. The XP-120 is almost on par with the rest in his tests; while I had some disappointing performance in a case, the HSF was not able to keep the CPU cooled with fan @7v where the tower heatsinks (Freezer/Noctua NH-U/SHogun) did it with ease.

 

reply