X58 Triple Channel DDR3 Memory Roundup! 8 Mid-range Kits Tested

Memory by thorgal @ 2009-04-09

In the ever raging sales battle among memory manufacturers, the Core i7 launch must have been the wind that shook the barley. While everyone was convinced i7 would be the real start of DDR3 technology, it also was a ´back to the drawing board´ call for most, having to come up with lower voltage memory parts - with decent performance - in a hurry. Four months into the launch now, we present you with a roundup of 8 mid-range kits from 8 different manufacturers. Begun, the new battle has.

  • prev
  • next

Patriot Viper PC12800

Patriot PC12800 "Viper"

The third manufacturer to be featured in our roundup is US-California based Patriot. Not as widespread in Europe as in the new World, they have been a valued memory manufacturer since 1985. Here are some facts about the Patriot company:

  • Mission Statement : to be the vendor of choice for the computer and consumer electronic industries with a commitment to service and quality.
  • Vision : commitment, focus on innovation in technology, product quality, and customer satisfaction are the key enablers of our future success.
  • Company Profile : established in 1985, Patriot Memory builds a full range of memory module and flash memory products, offering a perfect blend of quality and value. Patriot products include Extreme Performance (EP), Signature Lines (SL) and Flash Memory solutions (FM).
  • Manufacturing Process: to meet the growing global demand for its products, Patriot manufactures its Extreme Performance (EP), Dual Channel (DC) and Signature Line (SL) products in it own state-of-the-art manufacturing facility with highly skilled staff in Fremont, California USA. Patriot is a member of JEDEC. You can feel confident that your Patriot modules are of the highest quality available.
  • QA/QC Testing : Patriot Memory ensures that every module meets or exceeds industry standards. The manufacturing process begins with high-quality components and ends with rigorous functional testing to ensure each module's reliability and compatibility.


  • Madshrimps (c)


    This is the package the modules came in :

    Madshrimps (c)


    As the modules themselves are quite tall, they need a larger package than average to support them. Inside the cardboard box we find two blisters, one containing 2 modules, the other with one module. Patriot also thoughtfully includes a manual, something I always appreciate, even though 99% of the public for these kinds of memory products knows their way around a motherboard and a memory slot.

    Madshrimps (c) Madshrimps (c) Madshrimps (c) Madshrimps (c)
    Packaging, backside, blister


    Let's have a look at the real product now, pictured below :

    Madshrimps (c)


    The Patriot modules really look like they mean business, and look very promising indeed. The light blue color of the heatspreader is a Patriot trademark, the heatspreaders I should say, as they are two separate blades attached on both sides of the modules. As you can see, the modules are quite tall, although the underlying black PCB is of standard height.
    On the front of the modules, only the Patriot logo is displayed, while on the backside a sticker with the specifications is accompanied by a "DDR3" signature. All in all a very respectable package, sure to attract some attention when displayed inside your windowed case... Below are some more module details, click the thumbnails to enlarge them.

    Madshrimps (c) Madshrimps (c) Madshrimps (c)
    More module images


    As you can also see in the third thumbnail above, these are the specifications for the memory kit :

  • 1600MHz DDR3 (PC12800)
  • Latencies : 9-9-9-24-2T (CAS-TRCD-TRP-TRAS-CR)
  • Operating voltage : 1.65 Volts
  • 240pin DIMM
  • Parity : Unbuffered
  • Memory size : 3x 2048Mb

    After looking at the appealing package and the modules themselves, the specifications are a bit disappointing: they seem more in line with a value part than with a performance kit. First looks can be deceiving though, from the outside as well as the inside... Just read the overclocking paragraph and you'll know what I mean.




    Overclocking

    Time for some overclocking fun. The Patriot modules proved to be a bit more difficult to overclock as our first two candidates, as they seemed to have a curious quirk, at least on the Gigabyte board we tested on. The modules refused to work properly with the 2:12 memory divider once we hit speeds over 1600Mhz. While the standard setting (133Bclk 2:12) was not a problem, as soon as we increased Bclk the board refused to boot. Not to despair however, the 2:10 divider worked flawlessly, and provided some interesting results.

    First and most important, it seems that Patriot is very conservative when speed-labeling the modules, as our kit did not have any problem with the tighter cas 8 latencies at 1600Mhz, even with a command rate of 1T. Cas 8/1T, the kit even scaled up to 830Mhz (1680 Mhz DDR), an excellent result for a cas 9 kit.

    At cas 7, performance was adequate as well: the modules hit a respectable 745Mhz (1490Mhz DDR). The result for cas 9 (stock timings) was excellent as well, surpassing 1800Mhz DDR easily, to top out at 906Mhz prime stable, still at a command rate of 1T. This represents a 13% gain in speeds, which can be improved when you relax the command rate to 2T. Below are the screenshots from the prime tests once more (click to open)

    Madshrimps (c) Madshrimps (c) Madshrimps (c)
    Maximum Overclock cas 7, 8 and 9


    Next is G.Skill...>
    • prev
    • next
    Comment from Kougar @ 2009/04/10
    Quote:
    I decided not to include the results in this review yet, as there wasn't actually anything wrong with the kits at their rated speeds. Both did the rated speeds and timings without any issues, they just didn't overclock to any satisfying level.
    This has been observed with Corsair Dominator kits in other reviews. Link

    I was just about to buy a kit of OCZ Platinum, nice to see the overclocking results here, thank you. Should probably mention the 6GB OCZ Platinum 1600MHz kit is available for $80 shipped AMIR, cheapest 1600MHz kit of all those tested.
    Comment from blind_ripper @ 2009/04/10
    80$ , thats cheap!

    btw u got a pic mixed up @ page 8 from the OCZ's, cas 7 has the cas8 pic .
    althoughe very nice work thorgal
    Comment from thorgal @ 2009/04/10
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Kougar View Post
    This has been observed with Corsair Dominator kits in other reviews. Link

    I was just about to buy a kit of OCZ Platinum, nice to see the overclocking results here, thank you. Should probably mention the 6GB OCZ Platinum 1600MHz kit is available for $80 shipped AMIR, cheapest 1600MHz kit of all those tested.
    Yes, I read the xbit article, they come to about the same conclusion indeed.

    The Patriots can also be had for $79,99 now at Newegg, could be the OCZ's are equally cheap somewhere (they're $89,99 at Newegg).
    Comment from leeghoofd @ 2009/04/10
    Great work Ram "Torsten" Guy
    Comment from Kougar @ 2009/04/10
    Yes, but the Patriots are CAS 9. OCZ Platinum is CAS 7 (better than anything Corsair offers too).

    Didn't hear it from me: Newegg Promo code EMCLRLV42 for $10 off OCZ3P1600LV6GK ($80). Even less if buying NIB on ebay.
    Comment from Jaco @ 2009/04/11
    good article / review .

    Still reading ... lots of numbers

     

    reply