In-Depth LCD Buying Guide - What Monitor Should I Buy?

Others/Miscelleneous by rutar @ 2008-03-14

Before the LCD displays arrived, the choice of a monitor has been fairly easy. With CRTs you had screen size, refresh rates and price and you could be fairly sure that you did not have to worry about anything more. With LCDs, it is a different matter and this guide aims at helping you understand what the marketing gibberish means and what you really need to look for.

  • prev
  • Go to mainpage

Risks when buying LCDs

Risks when buying LCDs

Reviews and user reports often uncover a whole lot of things that can go wrong with an LCD. This section helps you to know the things you need to look for.

Dead/stuck Pixels

It is the year 2007 and we still have to worry about that issue despite that they are a lot less common. Some manufacturers like Viewsonic have 0 dead pixel warranties and you can buy dead pixel checks from some e-tailers and I think it is worth to look out for that (certainly avoid buying without a check from a site that offers dead pixel checks, you know how businesses are nowadays).

Madshrimps (c)
(Download Dead Pixel Buddy here)


Backlight bleed and brightness homogeneity

The backlight shines through the edges of the display or the edges or certain parts of the display are significantly brighter than the rest of the display. This is really annoying in movies and with dark backgrounds. User reports give you an indication if a manufacturer has issues in that area. The way the LCD is handled has a large effect on these issues, avoid any shipping companies that don’t handle packets well and don’t drop your LCD (it would change the orientation of the mirrors in the backlight that distribute the light of the lamps). LED backlight should cure this issue because they are less sensitive on drops.

Madshrimps (c)


Noisy displays

Imagine your LCD is beeping, whining or buzzing whenever it is on or even worse, when it is just plugged in. That does drive anyone insane in less than a day and the issue isn’t even limited to cheap displays. It is getting more common because larger displays are more likely to be affected. Reviews sometimes find it but user reports will certainly show if there are issues.


Review sites

Madshrimps doesn’t offer large monitor comparisons yet so here are some very useful resources when choosing a monitor: Vincent Alzieu from France is the most dedicated reviewer for large LCD display comparisons which he publishes in French and English.

  • Comparison database
  • Panel Type Search Engine
  • LCD reviews in French
  • Most LCD reviews from the link above translated to English
  • Benoît Dupont publishes his reviews in French
  • The Germans from offer reviews and a large database in German and English
    • prev
    • Go to mainpage
    Comment from geoffrey @ 2008/03/14
    Hey, nice work there Rutar, more of that
    Comment from Sidney @ 2008/03/14
    Hey Rutar,

    Is there another Rutar to critic your opinion?

    Excellent start.
    Comment from thorgal @ 2008/03/14
    Great work indeed

    Got another site for you that publishes screen types of LCD's : http://www.flatpanels.dk/panels.php

    Luckily you can choose English as well in the search page
    Comment from Rutar @ 2008/03/14
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by thorgal View Post
    Great work indeed

    Got another site for you that publishes screen types of LCD's : http://www.flatpanels.dk/panels.php

    Luckily you can choose English as well in the search page
    that is a great site

    *bookmarks*
    Comment from jmke @ 2008/03/14
    added to the links list
    Comment from Sidney @ 2008/03/14
    LCD displayport + touch screen from Origen may be available soon in 30"!!
    May be?
    Comment from Rutar @ 2008/03/15
    I think I discovered one more thing that is 100% true for LCDs:

    Just as with cars, it is better to buy a model that has been in production for 6-12 months than one that has just been released. That way the bugs are worked out and the production line knows how to make the product properly. Be aware that the distribution can easily add a 6 months delay!

    Rule of the thumb is: Buy only after the product has been out for 12 months in your country.

     

    reply