Test ResultsThe Silent Square lines up nicely with the rear 120mm fan on this DFI motherboard:
If you have a side panel with window you'll appreciate the LED fan Asus used, it gives the S² a touch of class. If however you don't have a window in your side panel (like me) this extra detail is lost.
The Silent Square seems like a capable heatsink, for the performance comparison I've included Asus' previous entry the X-Mars (with its fan set to auto speed) and the stock AMD Heat pipe cooler. The included BLUE led fan was used at 100/50% speed, I also installed my reference Delta 92mm fan. At full speed the Asus 92mm fan runs at ~1900rpm, at 50% voltage the rpm drops back to ~710rpm. (in comparison the open framed Delta runs at ~1500rpm @ 100% and ~690rpm @ 50%). Let's see how it did:
Very impressive results with the 92mm fans at 100%, the noise difference between the Asus and Delta is only ~1dBA; CPU temps are identical, yet PWM is slightly higher with the Delta fan. At low fan speed the noise drops to a very silent 35dBA and performance is still excellent. Let's see what happens when we increase CPU speed & voltage:
Any heatsink able to keep this hot K8 CPU running below 70°C at low noise is a worthy HSF solution, the Silent Square however falls into the "excellent" category, matching the CPU temp results of other high end heatsinks like the Tuniq Tower 120 and Scythe Ninja (
compare here). PWM temps are quite high but nowhere near critical values.
If Asus decides to release an upgraded version of the S² with 120mm support (and maybe throw in another heat pipe) they make take the performance/noise crown.
ConclusionThe Asus Silent Square is a very competent cooling solution, keeping temperatures down, whether the CPU is overclocked or not. The included fan at full speed is relative silent, yet turned down to 50% it becomes inaudible. The installation requires motherboard removal but that's the only drawback, the compact size of the HSF allows for wide motherboard/case compatibility.
Platform support is a bit unclear, the product page at Asus states S775/S478 for Intel and K8 S939/S754 for AMD, but it's motherboard compatibility list includes AM2 motherboards and a special 90° rotation bracket. Without the bracket the S² lacks AM2 support and the ability to freely rotate it in 90° steps on the K8 platform, this in turn can lead to a less than ideal orientation.
Edit: Update 20/10: Asus informed me that the Silent Square PRO supports AM2, not the version reviewed here. The special 90° rotation bracket is also only for the PRO version.
PRO
Excellent performance
Silent LED fan (inaudible at reduced speed)
Fair price ~€35/$45CON
not AM2 compatible
Orientation depends on socket, will not always be installed optimal on all motherboards (K8 S939) I like to thank
Asus for sending over the product for testing;
Questions/Comments:
forum thread