Battle of the Titans II: Swiftech MCX478-V vs Thermalright SP-94

Cooling/CPU Cooling by jmke @ 2003-11-18

Little over a year ago we put Swiftech?s greatest against Alpha?s best. The MCX4000 vs PAL8942 review is more then a year old. And it is time again to find out who?s the king of the Pentium 4 aircoolers.

  • prev
  • next

Results SP-94 vs MCX478-V

Results SP-94 vs MCX478-V:

First up we have the P4 running at default speeds:

Madshrimps (c)


Both heatsink are able to keep the CPU under 20°C over the room temperature, the SP-94 takes the lead at the lowest CFM, with a difference up to ~5°C. When the Vantec Tornado is used both heatsink perform extremely well, keeping the CPU under 30°C!


Now let's speed up the P4 to 3.2Ghz, the output is now 90Watt of heat!

Madshrimps (c)


The difference between the 2 heatsinks remains constant, and both turn in impressive results. The dead spot on the 90mm Papst fan is bigger then the 80mm explaining why it trails behind a small margin.

These heatsinks are at the top end of the P4 air-cooling solutions, the SP-94 has a small lead on to Swiftech, but both products will provide you with a lot of headroom for overclocking your Pentium 4 setup. And even when using a very silent FAN they will keep the CPU near the 40°C mark.

Zalman has been proven as a solid solution if you like silence, how does the Swiftech perform when we put it up against it? Lets find out ->
  • prev
  • next