Madshrimps News and interesting articles and howtos from the Web!Articles and Reviews, CPU Coolers, Cases, Motherboards, Videocards and more...Howto and guides on Modding and Optimising your PCFollow Interesting Discussions at our Forums!Find out more About Madshrimps and its crewStatistics - What article/howto is most popular and more!
[M]adness
HWFaq Hardware and Software Frequently Asked Questions - HWFaq
Contests Win Hardware! Join our contests now!
Search
Links
Sponsors
Send News
Video Card Comparison Charts

Intel Core i7 In-Depth Performance Scaling Analysis

Aircooled Heatsink Reviews

35x 120mm Fans Tested

Sponsors
.Priorweb
Arctic Silver
Asus
Caseking
CoolerMaster
Danger Den
Gigabyte
MSI
OCZ
PC-Cooling
Scythe
Swiftech
Tones
||-More-||
 
 
Intel Clarkdale vs AMD Phenom II with 785G – Mainstream Showdown
Intel Clarkdale vs AMD Phenom II with 785G – Mainstream Showdown
With the launch of Clarkdale by Intel, they have finally released a Nehalem for the masses, the Core i3 and i5 variations with integrated graphics are a direct competitor to the market segment currently held by AMD Phenom and Athlon CPUs. In this article we compare the performance of the IGP on the Intel Core i5 661 to and AMD system with 785G chipset.
Author massman
Editor jmke
Date 2010-01-11
Discuss 5 comment(s)
Print this Article

 
 


  Introduction : "Who cares about NDA?"

Less and less people, apparently. Although it's not our intention to make a big deal of this, again, we do wonder why we bother to stick to the NDA set by Intel when we could just buy the technology months in advance. Well, this article is exactly what we plan to do about it: instead of releasing a finished article the minute the NDA is over, we wait a couple of days. Yes, that's how we roll!

The advantage of this action is that we don't have to bother running all the uninteresting tests and focus on what interests us. Instead of the normal series of benchmarks, comparing the newly released technology against the existing technology and come to the conclusion that it's pretty decent stuff, we will be looking at how useful this Clarkdale is in comparison to the already existing Phenom II ... IGP solution! Will Intel crush its mainstream rival ?

Madshrimps (c)


As you probably already know, the Clarkdale differs from any other Intel technology released so far by the integration of a graphics processor on the CPU die. As the picture above shows, it's not integrated into the CPU itself, but it's located in the package.

The interesting part is that this redefines the concept of integrated graphics completely. Whereas this used to be a graphics core integrated either separately or into the Northbridge, it is now located under the same hood as the processor. This means: one chip less that draws power and generates heat, only one cooler needed to cool down the system and the possibility to make smaller PCBs housing the entire tech you needed.

The Clarkdale IGP

Again, I have to, no: want to, refer to other articles around the web if you want to know the exact specifics of the technology behind the integration of the graphics processor. In my humble opinion, there are only TWO important notes to make:
  1. The graphics core is build using 45nm transistor technology, ergo the biggest die on the cpu package
  2. The memory controller is located on the die of the graphics processor

In fact, only the latter is really interesting to ponder about. Let's go back to the design of the latest IGP technology: AMD's 785G housing the HD4200 (which is actually just the HD3300 with added DX10 feats, but that's not the topic of today). The graphics processor is located in the NB, which is connected to the CPU by the infamous HT Link. Now, any graphics core needs some sort of cache or memory to store data, so AMD developed two solutions: UMA and sideport. The UMA technology reserves a part of the system memory to store vga data, sideport memory is a dedicated memory chip located nearby the Northbridge also serving as storage for vga data. Now, there are two reasons why the sideport memory has been added to high-end IGP mainboards:
  1. Faster acces
  2. Power saving purposes

Both reasons are actually part of the underlying issue of using system memory to store vga data. When the IGP is in load mode, loading and storing data in the system memory takes up too much time to deliver decent performance. As the memory controller in the Phenom II is also located on the cpu die, the following path has to be followed from the IGP to the system memory:

IGP --> NB --> CPU --> IMC --> DRAM


And of course all the way back again. Having a dedicated amount of memory on the side, the sideport, reduces these latencies. An optimisation, yes, but sadly enough this solution also has its limitations as the maximum amount of sideport memory is a mere 128MB, a lot less than what current games require. In other words, although the problem is partially solved, using sideport memory only will not be a viable solution if you want to play some games at higher resolutions and quality settings.

Here's where the Intel engineers come in. Since the graphics processor is already integrated on the cpu die, the biggest latency bottleneck of the Northbridge is already removed. The brilliance of the design is that the memory controller has been integrated on the IGP die ... as close as possible to the GPU! No need for sideport memory ... another cost avoided!

(oh by the way, I've just hinted you on how you increase the performance of your HD4200 by overclocking: increasing the clock frequency of the HT Link and the NB will significantly increase the frames per second due to a faster transfer rate of vga data)

| Next ->>




Quick Page Jump:

More reviews in this category can be found below:

  • AMD 6 Core 1090T CPU Overclocked with LN2 and Benchmarked
  • Not Yet Another Core i7 980X Review - Overclocking With LN2
  • Intel Clarkdale CPU Overclocking With IGP Enabled - Reaching High BCLK
  • Intel Clarkdale vs AMD Phenom II with 785G – Mainstream Showdown
  • Intel Core i5 750 Review - Overclocking Phase-Change vs LN2
  • Intel Pentium E6300 Best bang for the buck ? Cache test revisited
  • Intel Core 2 Duo E7400 vs E8600: The battle of the caches!
  • Intel Core i7 920 and 965 XE CPU Review
  • AMD Phenom X3: One too little or one too much?
  • Mainstream Quad Core Processors Compared from AMD and Intel
  •  
     


    Copyright © 2001-2010 Madshrimps / JMkeOC.com, All rights reserved.
    Graphical Design by Dennis Kestelle, Programming by John Meys, Paul Meys and Frederik Colardyn, Overall Site design by John Meys

    All information and graphics contained in Madshrimps are sole property of the Madshrimps crew and may not be reproduced or copied in any manner without written permission from us.

    BTW-BE 0888919678

    ADS by G
     
       
     

    Search Madshrimps
     
     
    Google
    Search Madshrimps:

     
     

    Daily News
     
      Engineers Turn Robo...
    Intel almost halves...
    Windows Phone 7 Han...
    Geforce GTS 450 vs ...
    XFX Radeon HD 5970 ...
    Lucid UNITY Graphic...
    Seasonic X-400 Fanl...
    Farewell to ATI, AM...
    Intel's Core 2011 M...
    A $30 Adapter, a Wo...
    Intel to Acquire In...
    Intel Sandy Bridge ...
    ATI CrossFireX Appl...
    Mortgage worker got...
    Things to do if you...
    Thermalright HR-02 ...
    Core i7 2600K turbo...
    Scythe Ninja 3 CPU ...
    iD Software Condems...
    ATI's Catalyst driv...

    Syndicate Madshrimps Daily News with our XML/RSS Feed!

    Receive updates by e-mail

    Read more News...
     
     

    Sponsor Space:
     
     
     
     

    New Content
     
      Articles/Reviews:
    Gigabyte GA-880GMA-...
    Mad Catz Eclipse Wi...
    Foxconn NetBox-nT33...
    ARCTIC COOLING MX-4...
    ROCCAT Pyra Wireles...
    NAS Cases Compared ...
    ADATA Nobility Seri...
    DDR3 Memory Overclo...
    Tones Overclocking ...
    Shuttle XPC SH55J2 ...
    ASRock X58 Extreme3...
    Tones Overclock Aca...
    ADATA Superior Seri...
    Icy Dock MB668 Exte...
    AMD ATI RADEON HD 5...

    Howto and Guides:
    Building a 300W Fan...
    NVIDIA Geforce 8400...
    NVIDIA Geforce 8800...
    Reviving and Volt M...
    Protect the core of...