Madshrimps News and interesting articles and howtos from the Web!Articles and Reviews, CPU Coolers, Cases, Motherboards, Videocards and more...Howto and guides on Modding and Optimising your PCFollow Interesting Discussions at our Forums!Find out more About Madshrimps and its crewStatistics - What article/howto is most popular and more!
[M]adness
HWFaq Hardware and Software Frequently Asked Questions - HWFaq
Contests Win Hardware! Join our contests now!
Search
Links
Sponsors
Send News
Video Card Comparison Charts

Intel Core i7 In-Depth Performance Scaling Analysis

Aircooled Heatsink Reviews

35x 120mm Fans Tested

Sponsors
.Priorweb
Arctic Silver
Asus
Caseking
CoolerMaster
Danger Den
Dollarshops
Geeks.com
Gigabyte
MSI
OCZ
PC-Cooling
Scythe
Swiftech
Tones
||-More-||
 
 
SSD + Full Disk Encryption = Slow/Slower as HDD
SSD + Full Disk Encryption = Slow/Slower as HDD
Got a chance to test Intel X25-M G2 160Gb SSD; Dropped it in a laptop , Dell Latitude E6400/2Gb as well as Dell Precision/X5560/4Gb system. The desktop was run unencrypted, the laptop tests were run with full disk encryption (Utimaco Safeguard Enterprise).
Author jmke
Editor jmke
Date 2009-11-03
Discuss 0 comment(s)
Print this Article

 
 


  Full Disk Encryption + SSD

Got a chance to test Intel X25-M G2 160Gb SSD; Dropped it in a laptop , Dell Latitude E6400/2Gb as well as Dell Precision/X5560/4Gb system.

The desktop was run unencrypted, the laptop tests were run with full disk encryption (Utimaco Safeguard Enterprise).

The outcome on the desktop system was pretty much as expected, read speeds for the SSD were always superior, only when write speeds were tested, sequential write speeds, the HDD won. Random I/O the SSD crushes the competition.

On the laptop, were the SSD was supposed to provide a sweet performance boost, things were less encouraging. Without encryption the SSD acted as seen in our SSD vs HDD movie here

Once the drive was encrypted though... what a difference... the write speeds dropped horribly, the read speeds were a far cry from what to expect. In short, with encryption enabled I didn't notice a difference between the SSD and HDD laptop. Benchmark tools were limited in their efficiency as the encryption driver is quite low level, read tests were not possible, only ATTO worked "a bit" turning in 30-35Mbs/ read speeds on the SSD. Write speeds were measurable by using FC-test and creating the different file patterns, the results:

Madshrimps (c)


on the desktop workstation I was able to run HD Tune; To put extra stress on the I/O I launched 4 sessions of HD Tune Read speed at the same time, the SSD completely destroys the HDD here:

Madshrimps (c)


Access times were also very telling:

Madshrimps (c)


Unfortunately on the laptop system with Utimaco Safeguard (full disk encryption) performance is too similar to a normal HDD to justify the expensive storage. Most likely the Utimaco software will have to be patched/tweaked for SSD usage to take advantage of its performance, currently all read/write actions pass through the encryption driver, causing the bottleneck, and it's not CPU bound either, it never goes over 10% during heavy file transfers...

was quite saddened to see these results. So be warned if you have full disk encryption and want to invest in SSD.

What DOES work better is an encrypted volume for your DATA only, using truecrypt or similar, leaving the OS/Apps unencrypted on the SSD. But that was no option for me.

| Next ->>




Quick Page Jump:

More reviews in this category can be found below:

  • SSD + Full Disk Encryption = Slow/Slower as HDD
  • Vizo Luxon 3.5Inch External IDE/SATA HDD Enclosure Review
  • Acard ANS-9010 RAMdisk vs OCZ Vertex 30Gb SSD: Shootout
  • HDD Upgrade Time: Acard ANS-9010 vs Gigabyte I-RAM vs SSD
  • Attack of the HDD Dockings: Sunbeamtech,Sharkoon,Thermaltake
  • OCZ Vertex Real-World Test Caught on Tape: SSD vs HDD
  • Western Digital Scorpio Black, the none-SSD Laptop HDD Upgrade
  • OCZ Rally2 32Gb USB Stick Review
  • Super Talent Pico-C 8Gb Micro USB Stick Review
  • Corsair Voyager GT 16Gb and Voyager 4Gb USB Stick Review
  •  
     

    Copyright © 2001-2006 Madshrimps / JMkeOC.com, All rights reserved.
    Graphical Design by Dennis Kestelle, Programming by John Meys, Paul Meys and Frederik Colardyn, Overall Site design by John Meys

    All information and graphics contained in Madshrimps are sole property of the Madshrimps crew and may not be reproduced or copied in any manner without written permission from us.

    BTW-BE 0888919678

    ADS by G
     
       
     

    Search Madshrimps
     
     
    Google
    Search Madshrimps:

     
     

    Daily News
     
      Geforce GT 240 gets...
    This one is for Fai...
    EVGA, where did you...
    Try Google's Chome ...
    The French Bench 13...
    Confirmed: R2-D2 Fi...
    Windows SteadyState...
    Cedarview Atom 2011...
    OCZ Plans USB 3.0 b...
    USB 3.0 vs USB 2.0 ...
    Sapphire Radeon HD ...
    CoolerMaster Sileo ...
    Lian Li Armorsuit P...
    OCZ DDR3 PC3-12800 ...
    Amd Athlon 2 X3 435...
    Sapphire Radeon HD ...
    Sapphire Radeon HD ...
    InWin Maelstrom Cas...
    ATI Radeon HD 5970 ...
    Elixir 6 GB 1600 MH...

    Syndicate Madshrimps Daily News with our XML/RSS Feed!

    Receive updates by e-mail

    Read more News...
     
     

    Sponsor Space:
     
     
     
     

    New Content
     
      Articles/Reviews:
    Sunbeamtech Automat...
    Leadtek Geforce GT ...
    Gigabyte TweaKING O...
    Video Card Comparis...
    Cooler Master Lab T...
    Leadtek Winfast Gef...
    SSD + Full Disk Enc...
    GIGABYTE P55-UD3P M...
    Vizo Luxon 3.5Inch ...
    Intel Core i7 CPU W...
    OCZ Behemoth Double...
    P55 Roundup: Gigaby...
    Intel Core i5 750 R...
    MSI MOA 2009 Grand ...
    F1 Overclocking Com...

    Howto and Guides:
    Building a 300W Fan...
    NVIDIA Geforce 8400...
    NVIDIA Geforce 8800...
    Reviving and Volt M...
    Protect the core of...